修复同一 Agent 多并发会话记忆混乱问题 (#458)

### 问题现象
同一 agent 开多个并发会话时(如 A1=查南京天气、A2=查北京天气),A2 在多轮 ReAct 执行中会"突然去查南京天气",表现为 A1 会话的上下文泄漏到 A2 会话。

### 根因4:Agent 实例共享 + state 覆盖(确认,仅状态显示问题)
确认点:
- AgentService.java:83-90 agentInstances 按 (agentId, modelKey) 缓存,不含 conversationId
- AgentService.java:598-624 getOrBuildAgentForConversation 只按 (agentId, provider, model) 解析,不按 conversationId
- AgentService.java:530-545 withLifecycleFlux 无锁 ,A/B/C 完全并发
影响: A 完成设 IDLE → B 仍在运行但显示 IDLE → 状态显示错乱。 不会直接导致记忆串台 ,但对用户可见。

## 二、根因与症状匹配度总结
根因 匹配度 触发条件 串台通道 1. SessionSearchTool ★★★★★ LLM 多轮遇到困难时主动调用 session_search 返回并发兄弟会话消息 2. 审批重放无过滤 ★★★☆☆ Plan-Execute + 审批 + 并发 awaiting_approval 误取兄弟会话计划 3. 结构化记忆共享 ★★★☆☆ A 会话 LLM 主动 remember_structured 写入 prefetch 注入到 B 会话 4. Agent 实例共享 ★★☆☆☆ 任意并发 state 显示错乱(非记忆串台)

用户描述的"B突然去查南京天气"最可能是根因1 ——因为 system prompt 明确引导 LLM 在遇到困难时用 session_search 回忆历史,而 SQL 会返回并发兄弟会话的"南京天气"内容。

## 三、修复方案(按优先级排序)
### 方案1:修复 SessionSearchTool(最优先,直接命中症状)
改动点 A — SessionSearchTool 增加 ToolContext 参数,强制读取真实 conversationId:

SessionSearchTool.java:37-44

改动点 B — SessionSearchService 增加运行状态过滤,排除并发兄弟会话:

SessionSearchService.java:60-73 SQL 增加:

或更保守:只返回 status = 'completed' 的会话,排除 running / awaiting_approval 的并发会话。

风险评估: 改动 SQL 查询条件,不影响写入逻辑。 completed 会话才是真正的"历史对话", running 会话是"正在进行"不应被搜索。功能上合理。

### 方案2:修复审批重放跨会话取计划(确凿 bug,必须修)
改动点 A — PlanningService.findAwaitingApprovalContext 增加 conversationId 参数:

PlanningService.java:228-232

改动点 B — 调用方传入 conversationId:

StateGraphPlanExecuteAgent.java:100

风险评估: 需确认 PlanEntity 有 conversationId 字段(从之前排查看应存在)。改动最小,仅加查询过滤,不影响其他逻辑。

### 方案3:结构化记忆引入会话级隔离(改动较大,需评估)
问题: 当前 ownerKey = user:<requesterId> ,3 会话共享。如果改为 conversation:<conversationId> ,会破坏"用户长期记忆跨会话共享"的设计意图(用户画像、偏好等应跨会话)。

建议方案: 不改 ownerKey 机制,而是在 StructuredMemoryTool.remember_structured 的 system prompt 说明中 明确限制 只记住"长期有效的事实",临时任务结果(如天气查询)不应写入。或在 type 枚举中新增 transient 类型,该类型按 conversationId 隔离,会话结束自动清除。

风险评估: 改动较大,涉及记忆分层设计。建议作为中长期优化,本次先修方案1和2。

### 方案4:Agent 实例 state 按 conversationId 隔离(可选)
改动点: BaseAgent.java:33 AtomicReference<AgentState> state 改为 Map<String, AtomicReference<AgentState>> (按 conversationId)。

风险评估: 影响所有 getState() / setState() 调用点,改动面广。且这只是状态显示问题,不影响记忆串台。建议暂不修,或在前端按 conversationId 单独查询状态。

--------------------------------------------
本次完成bug1、2修复;3、4未动
This commit is contained in:
MIST 2026-06-30 09:23:26 +08:00 committed by GitHub
parent 181e81a236
commit dcc8c9aed3
No known key found for this signature in database
GPG Key ID: B5690EEEBB952194
5 changed files with 42 additions and 13 deletions

View File

@ -1530,10 +1530,11 @@ public class AgentGraphBuilder {
adopting a KB article as the user's project. adopting a KB article as the user's project.
## Session Search ## Session Search
- `session_search(agentId, currentConversationId, mode, query, limit)` search conversation history - `session_search(agentId, mode, query, limit)` search conversation history
- mode="recent": list recent conversations (titles, times, message counts) - mode="recent": list recent conversations (titles, times, message counts)
- mode="search": keyword full-text search across past messages - mode="search": keyword full-text search across past messages
- Use this to recall previous discussions, look up past decisions, or find context from earlier conversations - Use this to recall previous discussions, look up past decisions, or find context from earlier conversations
- Only completed sessions (not currently running) are included in results
## Tool Usage Guidelines ## Tool Usage Guidelines
When you have available tools, use them to access local system information, files, or execute commands. When you have available tools, use them to access local system information, files, or execute commands.

View File

@ -97,8 +97,8 @@ public class StateGraphPlanExecuteAgent extends BaseAgent implements StructuredS
log.info("[{}] Plan-Execute replay stream: conversationId={}", agentName, conversationId); log.info("[{}] Plan-Execute replay stream: conversationId={}", agentName, conversationId);
Map<String, Object> inputs = buildInitialState(userMessage, conversationId); Map<String, Object> inputs = buildInitialState(userMessage, conversationId);
// DB 恢复 awaiting_approval 状态的计划上下文 // DB 恢复 awaiting_approval 状态的计划上下文 conversationId 过滤避免并发会话误取
PlanningService.PlanResumeContext ctx = planningService.findAwaitingApprovalContext(); PlanningService.PlanResumeContext ctx = planningService.findAwaitingApprovalContext(conversationId);
if (ctx != null) { if (ctx != null) {
inputs.put(PlanStateKeys.PLAN_ID, ctx.planId()); inputs.put(PlanStateKeys.PLAN_ID, ctx.planId());
inputs.put(PlanStateKeys.PLAN_STEPS, ctx.steps()); inputs.put(PlanStateKeys.PLAN_STEPS, ctx.steps());

View File

@ -58,13 +58,17 @@ public class SessionSearchService {
/** /**
* List recent conversations for the given agent. * List recent conversations for the given agent.
* Excludes the current conversation and any still-running sessions to prevent
* cross-conversation context leakage in concurrent multi-conversation scenarios.
*/ */
public List<Map<String, Object>> listRecent(Long agentId, int limit) { public List<Map<String, Object>> listRecent(Long agentId, String currentConversationId, int limit) {
int effectiveLimit = Math.min(Math.max(limit, 1), 50); int effectiveLimit = Math.min(Math.max(limit, 1), 50);
String sql = """ String sql = """
SELECT conversation_id, title, message_count, last_active_time, create_time SELECT conversation_id, title, message_count, last_active_time, create_time
FROM mate_conversation FROM mate_conversation
WHERE agent_id = ? AND deleted = 0 WHERE agent_id = ? AND deleted = 0
AND conversation_id != ?
AND (stream_status IS NULL OR stream_status != 'running')
ORDER BY last_active_time DESC ORDER BY last_active_time DESC
LIMIT ? LIMIT ?
"""; """;
@ -77,7 +81,7 @@ public class SessionSearchService {
row.put("lastActiveTime", toLocalDateTime(rs.getTimestamp("last_active_time"))); row.put("lastActiveTime", toLocalDateTime(rs.getTimestamp("last_active_time")));
row.put("createTime", toLocalDateTime(rs.getTimestamp("create_time"))); row.put("createTime", toLocalDateTime(rs.getTimestamp("create_time")));
return row; return row;
}, agentId, effectiveLimit); }, agentId, currentConversationId != null ? currentConversationId : "", effectiveLimit);
} }
// ==================== MySQL FULLTEXT ==================== // ==================== MySQL FULLTEXT ====================
@ -93,6 +97,7 @@ public class SessionSearchService {
WHERE c.agent_id = ? AND m.conversation_id != ? WHERE c.agent_id = ? AND m.conversation_id != ?
AND m.role IN ('user', 'assistant') AND m.role IN ('user', 'assistant')
AND m.deleted = 0 AND c.deleted = 0 AND m.deleted = 0 AND c.deleted = 0
AND (c.stream_status IS NULL OR c.stream_status != 'running')
AND MATCH(m.content) AGAINST(? IN NATURAL LANGUAGE MODE) AND MATCH(m.content) AGAINST(? IN NATURAL LANGUAGE MODE)
ORDER BY relevance DESC ORDER BY relevance DESC
LIMIT ? LIMIT ?
@ -116,6 +121,7 @@ public class SessionSearchService {
WHERE c.agent_id = ? AND m.conversation_id != ? WHERE c.agent_id = ? AND m.conversation_id != ?
AND m.role IN ('user', 'assistant') AND m.role IN ('user', 'assistant')
AND m.deleted = 0 AND c.deleted = 0 AND m.deleted = 0 AND c.deleted = 0
AND (c.stream_status IS NULL OR c.stream_status != 'running')
AND LOWER(m.content) LIKE LOWER(CONCAT('%', ?, '%')) AND LOWER(m.content) LIKE LOWER(CONCAT('%', ?, '%'))
ORDER BY m.create_time DESC ORDER BY m.create_time DESC
LIMIT ? LIMIT ?

View File

@ -4,9 +4,11 @@ import cn.hutool.json.JSONObject;
import cn.hutool.json.JSONUtil; import cn.hutool.json.JSONUtil;
import lombok.RequiredArgsConstructor; import lombok.RequiredArgsConstructor;
import lombok.extern.slf4j.Slf4j; import lombok.extern.slf4j.Slf4j;
import org.springframework.ai.chat.model.ToolContext;
import org.springframework.ai.tool.annotation.Tool; import org.springframework.ai.tool.annotation.Tool;
import org.springframework.ai.tool.annotation.ToolParam; import org.springframework.ai.tool.annotation.ToolParam;
import org.springframework.stereotype.Component; import org.springframework.stereotype.Component;
import vip.mate.agent.context.ChatOrigin;
import java.util.List; import java.util.List;
import java.util.Map; import java.util.Map;
@ -33,13 +35,14 @@ public class SessionSearchTool {
- "recent"列出最近的会话标题时间消息数不需要 query 参数 - "recent"列出最近的会话标题时间消息数不需要 query 参数
- "search"按关键词全文搜索消息内容返回匹配的消息片段 - "search"按关键词全文搜索消息内容返回匹配的消息片段
适用于回忆之前讨论过的话题查找历史决策检索之前的上下文 适用于回忆之前讨论过的话题查找历史决策检索之前的上下文
注意只会搜索已完成的会话不会返回当前正在运行中的其他会话内容
""") """)
public String session_search( public String session_search(
@ToolParam(description = "当前 Agent 的 ID") Long agentId, @ToolParam(description = "当前 Agent 的 ID") Long agentId,
@ToolParam(description = "当前会话 ID用于排除当前会话") String currentConversationId,
@ToolParam(description = "搜索模式recent 或 search") String mode, @ToolParam(description = "搜索模式recent 或 search") String mode,
@ToolParam(description = "搜索关键词mode=search 时必填)", required = false) String query, @ToolParam(description = "搜索关键词mode=search 时必填)", required = false) String query,
@ToolParam(description = "返回结果数量上限,默认 10", required = false) Integer limit) { @ToolParam(description = "返回结果数量上限,默认 10", required = false) Integer limit,
ToolContext toolContext) {
if (agentId == null) { if (agentId == null) {
return error("agentId 不能为空"); return error("agentId 不能为空");
@ -48,11 +51,20 @@ public class SessionSearchTool {
mode = "recent"; mode = "recent";
} }
// ToolContext 强制读取当前会话 ID替代 LLM 自传防止并发会话记忆混乱
String currentConversationId = "";
if (toolContext != null) {
String fromOrigin = ChatOrigin.from(toolContext).conversationId();
if (fromOrigin != null && !fromOrigin.isEmpty()) {
currentConversationId = fromOrigin;
}
}
int effectiveLimit = limit != null && limit > 0 ? limit : 10; int effectiveLimit = limit != null && limit > 0 ? limit : 10;
try { try {
if ("recent".equalsIgnoreCase(mode.trim())) { if ("recent".equalsIgnoreCase(mode.trim())) {
return handleRecent(agentId, effectiveLimit); return handleRecent(agentId, currentConversationId, effectiveLimit);
} else if ("search".equalsIgnoreCase(mode.trim())) { } else if ("search".equalsIgnoreCase(mode.trim())) {
if (query == null || query.isBlank()) { if (query == null || query.isBlank()) {
return error("mode=search 时 query 不能为空"); return error("mode=search 时 query 不能为空");
@ -67,8 +79,8 @@ public class SessionSearchTool {
} }
} }
private String handleRecent(Long agentId, int limit) { private String handleRecent(Long agentId, String currentConversationId, int limit) {
List<Map<String, Object>> sessions = sessionSearchService.listRecent(agentId, limit); List<Map<String, Object>> sessions = sessionSearchService.listRecent(agentId, currentConversationId, limit);
JSONObject result = new JSONObject(); JSONObject result = new JSONObject();
result.set("mode", "recent"); result.set("mode", "recent");

View File

@ -224,12 +224,22 @@ public class PlanningService {
/** /**
* 审批 replay 上下文找到最近一条 running 且含 awaiting_approval 步骤的计划 * 审批 replay 上下文找到最近一条 running 且含 awaiting_approval 步骤的计划
* 返回恢复图执行所需的全部状态 * 返回恢复图执行所需的全部状态
* <p>
* conversationId 过滤防止并发会话误取兄弟会话的计划
*/ */
public PlanResumeContext findAwaitingApprovalContext() { public PlanResumeContext findAwaitingApprovalContext(String conversationId) {
PlanEntity plan = planMapper.selectOne(new LambdaQueryWrapper<PlanEntity>() if (conversationId == null || conversationId.isBlank()) {
log.warn("[PlanningService] findAwaitingApprovalContext called without conversationId, " +
"risk of cross-conversation plan pickup in concurrent scenarios");
}
LambdaQueryWrapper<PlanEntity> wrapper = new LambdaQueryWrapper<PlanEntity>()
.eq(PlanEntity::getStatus, "running") .eq(PlanEntity::getStatus, "running")
.orderByDesc(PlanEntity::getCreateTime) .orderByDesc(PlanEntity::getCreateTime)
.last("LIMIT 1")); .last("LIMIT 1");
if (conversationId != null && !conversationId.isBlank()) {
wrapper.eq(PlanEntity::getConversationId, conversationId);
}
PlanEntity plan = planMapper.selectOne(wrapper);
if (plan == null) return null; if (plan == null) return null;
List<SubPlanEntity> subPlans = subPlanMapper.selectList( List<SubPlanEntity> subPlans = subPlanMapper.selectList(